Did you know?  Check our Rare Books Page

Vain Tenderness: A (Mostly Futile) Sully Prudhomme Reading Guide

By Brian Hoey. Sep 7, 2017. 9:00 AM.

Topics: Poetry, Nobel Prize Winners

Literary-historical karma, as ever, sides with Leo Tolstoy. When the first Nobel Prizes were awarded in 1901, the great Russian novelist was considered the frontrunner for the literary prize. When he failed to win, there was public outrage, leading a number of Swedish artists and critics to sign an apologetic letter to Tolstoy, for fear that the Nobel Committee’s decision to snub Tolstoy would reflect badly on the country’s literary tastes and worse, offend one of history’s greatest writers. Regardless of whether Tolstoy himself had any desire to win the award (he didn’t), history has largely sided with the outraged parties, continuing to venerate Tolstoy while letting cobwebs spread over the legacy of Sully Prudhomme, the first winner of the Nobel Prize for Literature.  

570px-Sully_Prudhomme,_René-François-Armand,_BNF_Gallica.jpgSully Prudhomme, a fin de siècle French poet and philosopher, was a pioneering member of the Parnassus school. The poetic movement was based on a distaste for the perceived sentimentalism of the Romantic poets like Lord Byron and John Keats (and a love for the philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer) and boasted Stéphane Mallarmé, and Paul Verlaine among its ranks. (One is forced to wonder who the first Literary Nobel Laureate would have been if either of these two poets had survived a few more years). Prudhomme’s first collection of poetry, Stances et poèmes (1865) was critically acclaimed in its day and remains one of his more popular works (though, popular is a relative category; none of his books have been rated more than 10 times on Goodreads) and contains perhaps his best known poem, “Le Vase Brisé”.

Following his first book, Prudhomme would publish another dozen or so volumes of poetry. It’s difficult to single any of the collections out as better or worse places to start, in part because very little of his verse exists in English translation and still less is currently in print. There is an English language version of 1875’s Les vaines tendresses, but the quality of the translation may be hard to speak for. The Nobel Committee cited Prudhomme’s "lofty idealism, artistic perfection and a rare combination of the qualities of both heart and intellect," which befit the hyper-technical nature of the Parnassus school poets in general, but one wonders if this technical perfection led to verse that was almost interchangeable—which may explain why Prudhomme’s poetry was sometimes described as "competent but uninspired.”

leo_tolstoy.jpgLater in life, Prudhomme would eschew poetry, turning all of his creative energy to writing philosophy. Specifically, he wrote essays on aesthetics, free will, and 17th century French theologian and mathematician Blaise Pascal (La vraie religion selon Pascal (1905) collects his writing on Pascal). While readers of poetry might be understandably less interested in his philosophical output, it’s worth thinking about the fact that his and his fellow Parnassians’ poetry was, to a greater degree than the Romantics’, philosophical in nature. As a group, they championed an “art for art’s sake” aesthetic philosophy, which Prudhomme engages with in his critical writings. If Prudhomme’s status as the first winner of the Nobel Prize in Literature makes him an interesting historical footnote, his philosophical writings make for a worthwhile footnote to the footnote.  

 Browse the Nobel Laureate Collection

Brian Hoey
Writer and all around book nerd, Brian puts his English degree to good use turning words into magic. A great lover of beer, baseball, and books, he can write on Baltic Porter and Katherine Anne Porter with equal ease.


comments powered by Disqus


    About this blog

    How can I identify a first edition? Where do I learn about caring for books? How should I start collecting? Hear from librarians about amazing collections, learn about historic bindings or printing techniques, get to know other collectors. Whether you are just starting or looking for expert advice, chances are, you'll find something of interest on blogis librorum.

    Get blog notifications per email:

    Download the James Bond Dossier

    Recent Posts

    Book Glossary
    Get your free Guide to Book Care

    Blog Archive

    > see older posts
    A Guide to Historic Libraries Part I